Search This Blog

Sunday, June 27, 2010

Anxieties of Influence: Christopher Nolan’s “The Dark Knight” through the Prism of Michael Mann















(Note: This piece is heavily incorporated into a more thorough Christopher Nolan piece I have written in the wake of Inception. This current page has its merits and individual statements, but I would recommend readers, particularly Nolan enthusiasts, go there before investing a lot of your time here.)

In his recent book Cultural Amnesia, social critic Clive James collects a host of individuals whom are in danger of being taking for granted by the modern world, be it their triumphs, failures, ideas, etc. You can imagine my enthusiasm when the book ran my two favorite Manns in back-to-back chapters: film director Michael followed by German author Thomas.

James' reasons for including Michael Mann in his collection (one of the few directors to make the list, including Terry Gilliam and Chris Marker) had to do with his influence on other action directors, in addition to his perfection of the genre: Heat is like any number of other cops and robbers movies – just better than ever before. And other directors, on either the Western or Eastern hemisphere, big budget or indie, are so influenced by Mann that regardless of whether they choose to follow him or not stylistically, they have him in mind. As a director, Mann elevates the action dynamic to transcendent heights and marvelous spectacle; his ability to stylize a moment gives us much to chew on because, according to James, there's nothing else to look for in Mann. But it's so good, that it's all right that there's nothing to intellectually grasp in what we are viewing.

It's a little odd to begin an assault on someone who is praising a hero, but I must clarify that James is completely and utterly wrong. This is not unusual, being that Mann has often been the victim of trivialization. But in the emerging criticism on his work, maybe too academic to be influential, his ideas are becoming clearer – in addition to being very pertinent to the cultural discussion at hand. But James’ anxieties in dealing with Mann are similar to my own in the past, before this literature (articles by Jean-Baptiste Thoret; Blood in the Moonlight: Michael Mann and Information Age Cinema by Mark E. Wildermuth; The Cinema of Michael Mann by Steven Rybin). The need to properly discuss Mann has become more important in understanding his recent pictures, which have met with much derision and lack of understanding (Miami Vice and Public Enemies).

So how to interpret Mann? Before the recent literature, Richard Combs voiced a similar concern in his Film Comment article on Mann from March of 1996, dealing mainly with Heat. Combs stated that Heat is a crime epic unlike any other, a "cosmic crime film" where the Kubrick of 2001 is directing material by the Kubrick of The Killing. Combs was frustrated by what, if anything, was Mann really giving us that was new, beyond aesthetics and demythologizing the robber and cop? At that stage, 1996, Mann was in his fifties but only had a handful of films: Thief (1981), The Keep (1983), Manhunter (1986), and The Last of the Mohicans (1992), in addition to a pair of television shows that seemed to carry the same attitudes and motifs of his films (Miami Vice and Crime Story). He was the same age at Scorsese and the other movie-brats from the 1970s, but had emerged as merely a cult figure by the mid 1980s. By 1996, Steven Soderbergh (whose debut was 1989) had made just as many features as Michael Mann.

Mann is not simply an elegant stylist, like so many of the Hong Kong directors he has influenced, or the Western filmmakers he emerged contemporaneously with, such as Adrian Lyne, Tony and Ridley Scott, and Alan Parker (all of whom were based out of England before achieving mainstream Hollywood success; Mann was educated at the London International Film School). Before studying film, Mann was interested in politics and literature at the radical campus in Madison, where he became enthralled with the torrent of new ideas. No generic Hollywood Democrat, Mann's belief structure is concerned with how social structures control individuals. He was one of the few Americans to get up close with the organizers of the 1968 Paris student riots, his affiliation with mass media – as a student filmmaker – allowing him to do so.

Mann's relationship with politics extends into his tough-guy urban crime dramas: Thief isn't just about a streetwise safe-cracker (James Caan), but is about the proletariat being exploited, manipulated, and then revolting, his speech to his father/exploiter Leo (Robert Prosky) coming straight from Marx's labor theory of value; even looking at Miami Vice, the television show, the careful viewer will note how it is actually a ferocious anti-establishment show, a raw and melancholy perspective as told from the point of view of the pawn-like insiders within the system that manufactures criminals just as it swallows them up. The issues at play in Mann have to do with hegemony and control: brought about by sign systems and mass media, with great attention paid to the technology characters have at their disposal, which in fact swallows their sense of identity. The biological human yearning affiliated with love and basic relationships is at odds with the demands of the social system to which the characters belong: you can be a cop or a husband, a thief or a boyfriend – you cannot be both. The result, given the economic needs of having to work in a profession in which one is proficient, leaves the interiors of these characters blank. The cybernetic systems that link characters together (best represented by Mann with cell phones) put them in a state of dependency that destroys them as human beings. Longing for the real, they belong to the hyperreal: to airports, hotels, and hospitals rather than a Home, or with access to Freedom, an idea best represented in Mann's film version of Miami Vice when Crockett walks away from the ocean and into a hospital. The richness of Mann's ideas really came through much more clearly in his post-Heat cinema (the anxiety of which, in 1996, was: after Heat, where the hell can he go from here?): The Insider, Ali, Collateral, Miami Vice, and Public Enemies, all of which deftly deal with the Individual at odds with the social institutions that hinder his path to fulfillment, the streamlined vectors of machinery, video, and technological gadgetry at odds with the tumultuous natural environment in the background, something made explicit by his vivid utilization of high-def video's depth of field in his last three pictures. Mann is the center of Information Age Cinema.

Which brings us, finally, to The Dark Knight.

*

I am not simply a fan-boy bringing up Michael Mann for my own selfish reasons, as I realize that at this point I must sound a little like Harold Bloom constantly bringing up how Shakespeare – or Wallace Stevens – is responsible for everything, including boiling water. But Christopher Nolan made clear his indebtedness to Mann in interviews preceding the release of The Dark Knight this last summer, often bringing up how he wanted to capture Gotham City the same way Mann captured Los Angeles in Heat: this is the story of disparate individuals within the confines of a gigantic metropolis. In watching The Dark Knight, Nolan's homages to Mann are so overt that we can intertextually turn to Mann – in fact I believe we must – if we are to find a resonance. Nolan doesn't simply wink with his homage here, but literally seems to be screaming it. There are the slightest references: the imprisoning buildings surrounding characters discussing issues of corruption on a rooftop (Miami Vice); the Batman fighting through a crowd of thugs in the techno-saturated environment of a night-club (Collateral's amazing Koreatown shootout); the serial killer without a practical motive, whose motives are rooted in a twisted and enigmatic psychological fantasy (Francis Dollarhyde and Hannibal Lecktor in Manhunter); the vectors of light hanging over the laboratory of Lucius Fox (too similar to Mann's visualization of the fight auditoriums in Ali); and the domination of media as a means of communication (The Insider). These slight homages can be taken on their own as just merely homages. But rather, by aligning Nolan's film and its images in relation to the cinema of Michael Mann, Nolan gives us a clue to interpreting the whole sense of The Dark Knight, and what it is pondering as regards the age in which it was made and distributed. Here, we can garner a kind of ecstatic meaning in The Dark Knight that goes far beyond the tiresome and concrete questions of the film (e.g. Is Harvey Dent really dead? and that sort of crap). It's Nolan's affiliation with Mann that makes The Dark Knight not only a greater aesthetic treat than the typical comic book film (the same way Heat handed it to the generic crime film, including the far less memorable The Usual Suspects), but how it is also philosophically more rich and fulfilling than if we were to simply investigate it by itself.

The Dark Knight begins in a fashion that seems very uncharacteristic for what its "sign" (the bat symbol) would be duly processed as by a collective audience: the Special Effects Comic Book Movie with a good dosage of gothic ambiance. Rather, it begins in the midst of action on a beautiful midday, aerially photographing a city far removed from the gothic Gotham of the past, even removed from the spectacular sci-fi metropolis of Nolan’s preceding chapter, Batman Begins. From that opening shot over the city, it sure looks a lot like contemporary Chicago. Nolan is filming a heist taking place, not pausing to let us know what exactly is happening; it is extremely well organized with professional burglary tools (the protagonist in Thief carries the exact same safe-cracking equipment used by The Dark Knight's robbers).

When I say that Nolan is not simply homaging Heat so much as screaming it, the opening sequence is evidence. It is relentlessly Mannian, and anyone who has seen and appreciated Heat will be able to pinpoint the marvels of its influence. The daylight is the same as in both of Heat's robberies. The steely veneer of the city. The masks. The low tracking shots circling the masked robbers. The banks and how the robbers operate within the banks (one of the Joker's goons yelling "Sit down!" could have been taken directly from Tom Sizemore's Michael Chirito in Heat). And, most conspicuously of all, Nolan's use of music scoring, which in its uniqueness – electronic programming, layered guitars, strychnine strings – mirrors Elliot Goldenthal's Kronos Quartet-performed Heat score. To top it all off, Nolan casts William Finchter, who portrayed corporate criminal Roger Van Zant in Heat, in a stellar cameo as the aggressive bank manager who tries to fend off the bank robbers.

This style may be a precise mimic, but what does it all amount to and what is it trying to communicate? How are we to intertextually interpret this, using Heat as a resource? Going back to Heat's opening moments, we are introduced to our master criminal, Neil McCauley (Robert De Niro), melding into the crowd at a train station, dressed in an ambulance driver uniform, so attuned to remaining inconspicuous and not leaving a trace of himself that we notice that he uses his elbows to open doors, so that he will not leave fingerprints. Like a ghost, he is able to slip from one hyperreal environment (a train station) into another (a hospital), casually stealing an ambulance which will be used for a complex armored car heist. We see the heist in progress – McCauley working with his close associates, each relying on the other like parts of a working clock. Before the robbery begins, each robber puts on a hockey mask – some black, others white, introducing the fogginess of moral stances in the picture. There is no black and white, only grey.

Most appealing is the moral position of both pictures. Mann's thieves, whether in Thief or Heat, may be social criminals, even sociopathic (Mann is fond of saying of his criminals: "He cares about his kids, he doesn't care about your kids."), but they have a kind of fraternal morality – a deep camaraderie based on trust, enabling them to act effectively. When someone decides to forge a kind of singular "self-ness” and thereby imposing his ego on the clockwork process, like the new-hire rapist Waingro (Kevin Gage), the result is disorder (McCauley's solution is simple and mechanically reflexive: kill him and get rid of the body).

The bank being robbed in The Dark Knight, it turns out, is a bank used by Gotham's gangsters for funneling their money. The bank manager (Finchter) reminds this to the clown-faced bank robbers while firing his shotgun. He mentions "honor, loyalty," and seems to represent a kind of closet morality amongst gangsters, an underworld conscience and coherent structuralism. Appropriately, this group of masked thieves is a wildcard, lacking a moral code. The perfection of the constructed plan (just as precise as we would expect from a McCauley in terms of timing) is dependent on one criminal killing another: The alarm expert is shot by the safe cracker. The safe cracker is shot by the man covering bank customers. The bus driver kills the coverage guy. The Joker kills the bus driver. There is a pronounced lack of the individual here: the masked criminals are a clone of each other, with no common denominator or base, indicating that the Joker truly is a wild card worthy of his title. More than a character with a body, he is more of a force, not restricted by real space or time. With no ground, he has no Identity – no morality, no ethics, no structure, nothing. "What do you believe?" the bank manager demands to know. Nolan responds with the stunning revelation of the man behind the mask: The Joker (Heath Ledger), his actual face a replica of his persona, the impact of the revelation matched by the burst of music: "I believe…that whatever doesn't kill you…makes you stranger." The Joker then disappears, McCauley-like, driving a bus into the simulacrum: other buses in front and behind it, a hyperreal element dissipating into the ether of binary repetitions. That his face uttering cryptic credos should match the mask on top indicates that the Joker is not a Self with a genuine center, though Ledger occasionally may give hints of a person with human motives. He is masks all the way down, far removed from the Jack Napier (Jack Nicholson) of Tim Burton's 1989 Batman. He ultimately lacks explanation, existing in no geographic reality with no Reason – which is why it is not entirely too bothersome that, for closure's sake, the Joker does not die a comic book villain's death at the end of the picture.

This leads to the compelling juxtaposition between Batman/Bruce Wayne (Christian Bale) and the Joker, both men wearing masks, and both men with moral cloudiness surrounding them. In Heat, McCauley is devoted to keeping himself away from a "ground self,” a philosophy disrupted by a love relationship with a graphic designer, Eady (Amy Brennenman). Having initially told her that he was a businessman “working in metals,” it is through the television that Eady learns of McCauley's real identity and occupation as a bank robber, indicating that the post-modern technological world in which this film takes place acts as more of a cover for individuals in real space and time than for hyperspace or hypertime (the television, or heat-sensing surveillance tools). McCauley's double is Al Detective Vincent Hanna (Al Pacino), a great investigator who cannot sustain a meaningful relationship with anyone, as we observe friction with wife Justine (Diane Venora), in this his third marriage. As long as he is committed to his work, Hanna’s relationships can never be fulfilling. A master detective who is bent on intimidating snitches for information (his histrionics are not Pacino overacting; they are essential to the performative character), Hanna can never turn off, and when he does, he is exhausted with little left to give his family. Instead of conversation or discussion, he turns to the television, which emerges as his closest link to intimacy, indicated by the hilarious, if wrenching scene where he discovers Justine’s infidelity. The TV being watched by the poor, awkward Ralph, Hanna grabs it, taking it with him, angrily intimating Ralph just as he does to his snitches: “You do not get to watch my fucking television set!” McCauley and Hanna emerge as a perfect marriage, and the most honest conversation between two characters in Heat transpires during their mid-movie cup of coffee, where their technique of trying to intuit information about the other gives way to a discussion about dreams and motivations. McCauley reminds Hanna that his pursuer will not be able to sustain a marriage if he continues his work as a detective, just as the Joker reminds Batman, who – as Bruce Wayne – cannot have a relationship with Rachel Dawes (Maggie Gyllanhall) as long as he's a masked crime fighter, that there is no place for normalcy in his life: "You complete me,” the Joker tells him. The one needs the other.

The paths to freedom and fulfillment that McCauley and Hanna seek in Heat are obscured by their occupational personae – or superhero/supervillain masks, in accordance with the comparison to this comic book film. The final moments of Heat visually communicate this idea. The wonderfully spectral chase through LAX leads to a environment full of technology, where the machines are built solely for other machines. The passions of the two men disintegrate beneath the booming airplanes above. McCauley, having been shot by Hanna, dies holding his shooter's hand. In a wide shot, Mann shows McCauley on the left, the runway lights flashing behind him, indicating his need to be in constant movement, always hiding, while Hanna is on the right, the city's buildings behind him, positioning him (in a very Batman-like fashion) as a doomed administrator/crime-fighter. The two are opposites and yet strangely mirrors of the other. The Dark Knight's relationship to Heat relates to a cyber noir motif, based on the fatal dance between doubles/opposites that are microcosmic representations of a technologically advancing world disallowing individuals to realize any genuine and grounded sense of Identity, technology being tied with corporate and social structures.

Mann's attention to technology and communication is vital here. No other director has characters utilizing a telephone so often (the cell phone is a character unto itself in The Insider); the era of Information, where everything is digitized, compresses space and time to the extent that the meat-self evaporates and becomes virtual. In The Dark Knight there is confusion over the real and unreal, or rather the hyperreal, where meatspace, or physical geography, is taken for granted. Notice Maroni's (Eric Roberts) flippancy after being threatened by Batman with a two-story fall; Batman soon reminds Maroni of the actuality of real space when the gangster's ankles are broken upon collision. As I said, the Joker seems to transcend temporal and spatial boundaries, which is why he is such a horrifying villain. He emerges as a walking panopticon, always seeing, always present, in any disguise or form. He has no concrete origin or past; his stories deliberately contradict each other, much like Mann's character of Vincent from Collateral, who chooses not to exist in a real link-chain with other beings. He also flies between genders, wearing a female nursing outfit at one point. The Joker seems to want Batman to give into the same virtual identity, embracing his freak-ness, which places him outside of the circumscriptions of morality and humanist thought structures. This is the Joker's challenge when he desires Batman to hit him with the Batcycle. The head-on collision would be a confirmation of the Batman's neglect for appreciating the physical impact of real space. The Joker would fuse his rival with the deadness of just another digital movie effect, of bodies without blood and space without substance. "In the real world, there are ramifications," Michael Mann has said, an existential reference to chains of human relationships. This philosophically relates to how human beings interact with their environment: a kind of base nature that technology, the digital, is seeking to obscure.

The Joker, or the technological post-human, wins the battle. His plot literally evaporates Bruce Wayne's love, Rachel, into nothingness (the impact of the explosion would leave little trace of her physical existence), and in retaliation, Batman (who 'has no limits'), adopts an unethical technique of mass surveillance – utilizing a sonar system via cell phones enabling him to completely master space and bear the same panoptical capabilities possessed by the Joker. Technology, the cell phone, the tool of disembodied information, is what separates us from the human world of honest relationships. Batman becomes 'the dark knight,' someone morally or ethically ambiguous with his techniques, committing – out of necessity – to the hyperreal designs of social structures more than to the integrity of the people he seeks to protect. Notice how he engineers the fate of Harvey Dent (Aaron Eckardt), a once idealistic DA who has become a sociopathic killer seeking vengeance: Harvey Dent? Alive or dead? Doesn't matter. The visible sign as given by the system – "Mission Accomplished" – is all that matters. Harvey's own flesh has evaporated too, simply in the design of politics and mass control. It is similarly by the tools of disembodied information that the Joker finds his release from the confines of his cell – or body: it is inexplicable how an inmate got a cellphone implanted within his flesh, which is triggered to explode by the Joker. Technology decimates the Real Body. We are all sonar in the anarchy given by the villain.

It is here worth pointing out how the Joker is similar to the kind of criminal Mann portrays in his Red Dragon adaptation, Manhunter. Francis Dollarhyde (Tom Noonan) and Hannibal Lecktor (Brian Cox) seem to have no boundaries – or motives. Regarding inexplicable murders, a detective admits, "In the case of a robbery, I search fences, because I know a robber's motive is cash money. Here, none of us have motive. None of us have shit and we know it." The motives exist in fantasies, the hidden spaces not having to do with physical causality. "Some men just want to watch the world burn," Alfred (Michael Caine) notes in The Dark Knight, commenting on the kind of criminal Batman might be dealing with in the Joker. These characters are more threatening – Dollarhyde, Lecktor, the Joker – because they are untraceable. Their point of origin is scrambled, like the television set image in Dollarhyde's house. He is a transmission signal and, in a videoscopic world of mass images and screens, we too exhibit signs that may be interpreted as sociopathic regarding the acknowledgement of fellow beings. As Muhammad Ali (Will Smith) says in Ali, "Yeah I know where Vietnam is. It's on TV."

Even so, there is hope. The Joker's plan to have one boat-load of hostages kill another boat-load (the question being, who will kill in order to save themselves first?) backfires; he is depending on the humans in either boat to take the real existence of the people on the other boat for granted; yet both sides acknowledge the sentient beings they are able to kill, and they choose to act altruistically.

Nolan's picture is asking questions about moviegoers in general: he is insistent, much like Mann is, of using real spaces and bodies for shooting, and dislikes the hampering dependence on CGI effects. The action hero has forsaken itself to the land of the unreal and into the realm of Resident Evil-like pretenders, the scallywags of cinema, Indiana Jones being the latest casualty this past summer. Just as Mann was taking the crime film back from post-modernist irony in 1995 (in the wake of Pulp Fiction and the Tarantino copycats), Nolan is acting with a similar sincerity in salvaging superhero fantasies from being full-length videogames, and back to the richness of raw meatspace moviemaking. In discussing the quandary of the real and the unreal, the crime fighter and the criminal, the analog and the digital, the meat vs. the hyper, The Dark Knight warns of the danger in surrendering giving to the virtual identity as opposed to the grounded, examined Self. To fall back into technology for convenience's sake traps our heroes in a confused pixilated mist.

Real Bodies, False Identities: Darren Aronofsky’s “The Wrestler”




















I might as well disclose how I grew up a big professional wrestling fan. Yes, yes - given my Halloween costume of two years ago – as Rowdy Roddy Piper, joined by the Hoadley brothers as Hulk Hogan and Macho Man Randy Savage - I'm sure some of you know. And to this day, whenever Erik (of the Hoadleys) and I hang out for a weekend, joining our diet of pizza and beer is the equally unhealthy dose of bad wrestling from the land of long-long ago. Our speech patterns gradually become more juvenile over the weekend, until we have finally regressed back, Benjamin Button-like, to our adolescence, to a time before rent, love, taxes, and insurance. Eventually, we reach a point of no return, identifying with our pro-wrestling heroes by referring to ourselves in the third person (The Niles says, or The Hoadley is going to, etc).

It's easy to be ashamed of liking professional wrestling because, well, on its surface it’s a little silly. Basically a bunch of guys aggressively groping each other while in their underwear. But that “stupid” is also very funny (particularly with beer), and even contagious. As a child, my dad took me to the Civic Center, sometimes with my sister, to see Hulk Hogan, Piper, and the whole group of "Superstars". And my sister would get just as into it as I was – perhaps more. I had all the LJM toys, now entrusted to my younger brother who is planning on re-painting them. And I almost cried on February 5, 1988, when Hulk Hogan lost the championship to Andre the Giant, a day dubbed by Hulkamaniacs as Black Friday. Hogan losing brought into question the existence of God and purpose in life, being that Hogan was supposed to be "Immortal": he can't lose. The way to lose to Hogan is to do your finishing move on him – but you need to do your finishing move in order to beat anybody. The bad guy wrestlers would thus be in a catch-22. The sun had been eclipsed on Black Friday, 1988, and I grew into the weariness of puberty.

This was probably a little off-putting for my dad, who endured tapings of Saturday Night's Main Event on the weekends, when he would much rather be watching Benny Hill. He would stress to me that it's not real – it's totally fake. They don't get hurt. Here, let me take you to Roosevelt High School – there's real wrestling there. However, Real wrestling was, as we all know, boring and even closer in appearance to homosexual pornography.

Baseball helped to partially subdue the wrestling thing, though video games and Nintendo, again to my dad's dismay, swooped in to steal me away from the real world and into an environment where my body was treated to hours in front of a television and projecting my ego onto 2-dimensional landscapes with action figures in better shape than me, their actions dependent on my control. I looked like many-a-man that loved videogames and wrestling: unhealthily scrawny, thick glasses, bad teeth, sometimes a mouth breather, wearing socks pulled up to my knees with short-shorts covering tighty-whiteys. If only I'd discovered D&D and comic books, I would be complete.

This bespeaks the divide between the Real World and the Virtual one, of videoscreens and false identities, between real flesh and geography, versus the artificial. The mantra regarding wrestling is thus repeated: "It's so fake." To quote a nice priest that tried to quell the rough-housing of my sixth-grade class at St. Hubert’s Catholic school: "When Macho Man Randy Savage jumps off the top rope and delivers the flying elbow of doom into the Big Boss Man, that's not real. When Earthquake jumps and squishes Hulk Hogan, the Hulkster's not really hurt. Y'know. When Ultimate Warrior gorilla-presses Ravishing Rick Rude and drops him to the mat, then gives him the Warrior splash of super-doom, that's not real." This wasn't beyond us. We accepted wrestling as entertainment. We were more befuddled as to how Father Steve knew so damned much about WWF. Maybe if we pooled our money, could we all come over and catch Summerslam and Royal Rumble at the church rectory.

But something bothered me, even then. These men in the ring are real men, with real bodies. And there's no damned way that some things, when colliding with real flesh, don't hurt. Who are these men? And what happens when they get old? I mean, they are not like Jesse Ventura in The Running Man, digitally created so that a digital Arnold Schwarzenegger can finally be killed for the network heads. In the 1990s, some of these men died, in the ring and out. Owen Hart, Curt Henning, Rick Rude, Junkyard Dog, Big Boss Man, and others. Some, like Chris Benoit, went bad-shit crazy and killed their families and then themselves, probably related to a bad dose of pain-killers. And others, from the heyday of the 1980s, would pathetically endure, with sagging muscles, and protruding guts. This was their life – a career with no 401K, doing the only thing that they knew.

Their bodies are ripped apart, and then put together again by medications (Hulk Hogan doesn't have a real knee anymore, I think). This is how they get paid. Unless they are good talkers, like Ventura, who was, after his spinal problems forced him to retire, arguably the best color-commentator in the history of the sport. They must use their bodies for capital and survival. When the body does not work, they are functionally useless. These guys, once breathing symbols of Ronald Reagan's pumped-up "USA!" aggressiveness and righteousness, are now a representation of our own economically feeble times, when all the subprime loans are being called in for payment. The body was living on borrowed time and money, so to speak, and now it might as well not exist, like so many other Americans who thought they were part of the Middle Class, of a Normal Life. They are not real, after all, with their families, romances, and domiciles. In the dark days of 2008, they are labor, meat, barely held together, sustaining themselves on technological and medicinal means until they expire, like an old vehicle.

This is what Darren Aronofsky's The Wrestler is about, and why it’s an important film to watch and discuss at the present moment.

***
The Wrestler begins with Quiet Riot's "Bang Your Head" (at least I think it's Quiet Riot), the camera scrawling over magazine covers from the 1980s, which capture the career heights of Randy "the Ram" Robinson (Mickey Rourke). He was an adored sports entertainment icon, and the magazines indicate that his greatest feud, peaking during a match at Madison Square Garden, was against “The Ayatollah,” the decade’s token Middle Eastern bad guy: USA vs. Iran, and the war that settled the score (to borrow a famous wrestling tag line) set in the squared circle rather than a battlefield. The Ram never lost to the Ayatollah, because America didn't lose. Twenty years pass. The carefree head-banging of Quiet Riot is quelled by the deconstructive post-rock of Kurt Cobain, pessimistic in nature, shunning the previous decade’s glam. Cobain is called a "pussy" by the Ram, who adds, "Nineties fuckin' sucked."



Randy is now wrestling at VFWs and school gyms, taking in as much as a modestly popular local band does during gigs. He lives in a trailer that he can barely afford, sleeping in his van when the landlord locks him out for not paying the rent. He works part time at a grocery store, stocking the docks for a pip-squeak boss, taking any available hours that don't conflict with his wrestling schedule. For recreation, he frequents a strip bar, having Rolling Rocks, tequila, and lap dances from his favorite stripper, Pam (Marisa Tomei), with whom he has his only meaningful conversations. Well into his fifties, Randy has no plan or no retirement option, and needs steroids, blow, and painkillers to keep him sustainable for action. The pain his body endures is all too real, and Aronofsky accentuates each blow Randy receives, filmed in hand-held close-up. On the mat, Randy will cut himself with razor blades to give the illusion that his opponent has busted him open. He sacrifices himself for the performance. Pam equates Randy to Jesus, another guy who gets the shit kicked out of him for two hours, but that "Passion" is meaningful, powerful, even entertaining for the spectators. She sees the symbolism (a little heavy-handed perhaps) in Randy's ring-name: the sacrificial ram that dies for the sins of the world.

Both of these characters, Pam and Randy, dwell in double worlds. They have two names. Randy's real name is Robin Raminski, and he doesn't like being called by his last name, indicating attachment to the persona he has created – or a painful estrangement from his origins that remind him of who he really is; Pam has a stripper name, Cassidy, in a profession that is just as fake as Randy's, though contingent on the performance, even suffering, of the body. Their conversations are simulated conversations, because Randy has to pay for her time, and she is wary of speaking to him as anyone other than as a customer. Randy has a daughter, Stephanie (Rachel Evan Wood), with whom he is estranged because of too many broken promises. He was better at playing his invented role as wrestler than the natural role as husband and father.

At this stage in his life, Randy is fine with his solitude. He is focused on simply keeping his grip on the present: paying the rent, pumping his body up for the next big match, tanning, hair, etc. He has short-term goals because that's all he can afford. He purchases illegal medications in the locker room, costing him $995, though the seller, a jacked superman, is fine with taking $400. This exchange is analogous to so much deregulized subprime lending that led to the housing crisis of the last year, a housing bubble that, economists warned, would lead to a bubble burst (September 15, 2008). The body of Randy will also eventually burst. His body is not his own, much as most homeowners don't actually have houses (the banks own the houses). We can hear the high-pitched sound whenever he puts his hearing aid in or takes it out; his experience of living is dependent on technology, or outside forces. His heavy breathing is the result of a split clavicle from 1988. It hurts for him to move, and Mickey Rourke's performance incandescently yet naturally communicates the soreness of each step. The body is running out of time, though the character of The Ram cannot exist in Time. His own Being is illusory. His bubble bursts in the form of a heart attack, following a hardcore match in which his body endures a staple-gun, barb-wire, broken glass, and a fork-gouge. He wakes up in a web of tubes, keeping him breathing, and is sedated by injection so that he can sleep while he undergoes bypass surgery.

Randy cannot wrestle, the University hospital doctor tells him. He can only moderately exercise. If he does wrestle, he will die. In effect, Randy cannot be who he is, or the self he has created and known for the past 30 years. At last, he realizes how alone he is. At an American Legion event where washed-up wrestlers gather to sell autographs and videotapes for fans, Randy observes his "frat brothers" (as Roddy Piper calls his comrades), and how their bodies depend on canes, wheelchairs, colostomy bags, etc. At home, he puts on his glasses and looks at an old photo of Stephanie. He tries reading. He gives in to the lure of Nintendo, asking a neighbor kid to join him.

The two play Randy's own wrestling game, enacting the 8-bit primitive characters of the Ram and The Ayatollah. The kid talks about newer games involving the war in Iraq, wherein the player is either a marine or British special forces on specific missions. We notice how, as Randy and The Ayatollah dish it out on the screen, that America's ideology hasn't changed much; just the technology has. It's just that better graphics have made the virtual more real. The kid comments on Randy's own game: "God, this is old." Later on, Randy tries jogging and almost suffers another heart attack. His body cannot keep up with the man he immortalized in 8-bit 1988 Nintendo.

He wants to have a "real" discussion with Pam, who undergoes the exchange cautiously (she has a "don't involve yourself with customers" policy). She amiably tells him to see his daughter, and then gets out of Randy’s car as quickly as she can. Randy says "Stephanie" to himself and goes to find her. Of course, in kind of a movie-cliché situation, Stephanie wants none of it, and tells Randy to leave her alone.

He takes more hours at the grocery store. At the deli counter, where he has to interact with customers (something Randy dislikes), Randy is first controlled by the customer number machine ("Number 47..."), but gradually finds a groove transcending his occupational circumscriptions and he moves into a more genuine and humane interaction. We notice that he gives up clicking on the number machine altogether, sometimes throwing the customers meat and cheese like a friendly football pass, dancing behind the counter. He will retire from wrestling.

Pam, who is as interested in Randy as she is cautious to know him, offers to help him find Stephanie a present, an action that will attempt to heal the rift. It is the first time he sees Pam in daylight, without sleazy makeup or clothes. He is only more attracted to her, and she more reticent to communicate. Having a beer together, they bond over their distaste for the 1990s. She also discloses that she has a son, adding another dimension of broken beauty to her. This is intertextually an interesting moment, as much has been made of how Mickey Rourke mirrors Randy, in light of his fall from great heights during the 1990s. But the same can be said of Marisa Tomei, following her Oscar win in March of 1993. In her, we see the repeated motif of faded dreams and what could-have-been (despite great supporting turns in Before the Devil Knows You’re Dead and In the Bedroom). There's a stink of rotten longing in The Wrestler, and the need to pull ahead of the pit of the past, whose demons cling tightly to the victim's heel.

This idea comes through more clearly as Randy convinces Stephanie to come with him to the Jersey shore, where years ago the two of them used to visit a fair. He would take her to the haunted house; she would get so scared that she would cry, but then beg him to take her back immediately after they escaped. She doesn't remember these details, but they have pummeled him as much as any physical punishment in the ring. "I tried to forget all about you," he confesses. As an unreal character, it would be easier for him to delete the real people in his life, but he is ultimately still a body, still human, and this is impossible. The two of them illegally enter an old ballroom, indicating that human bliss is constantly subterfuged by the regulations of governance, and he leads her in a waltz. She wonders of all the dances that must have happened here in the past, and how that contrasts to the ballroom's present ruin. But this dance is real, isn't it? Having its own magic, though the music is created by a movie director, the tenderness executed by a team of technicians and artists? Identity is not in celluloid, a videoscreen, or a magazine cover. It is experienced through our bodies – heart and mind.

But in Randy’s quest for normal and stable relationships in a life that for him has been mostly fabricated is derailed. Pam states that their relationship is not real. He has to pay for her time. This woman, who's become his confidant during lap dances, has never existed. Feeling self-pity and anger, Randy goes to another bar, does blow and picks up an easy woman with a fireman fetish. He wakes up wearing fireman boots; even in the most rudimentary and short-term of relationships, Randy must adopt another persona. He falls asleep in his trailer and misses a planned dinner with Stephanie, who does to him what he has tried to do to her: she psychologically deletes him. To her, he might as well have never existed. Now he realizes that not only is he alone, but in his pursuit of something real, he is fundamentally Nothing and useless. He angrily walks off his job, punching a meat slicer as if to punish the Ram's body that has made him a spiritual vacuum. Nihilistically, he agrees to do a rematch with The Ayatollah, a 20-year-anniversary event that will generate a big crowd. Why not? Being in the ring is all he knows, and is the only place he is acknowledged as a human being.

This nihilism reminded me of Frank (James Caan) in Michael Mann's 1981 film Thief, about a man who realizes that, in his pursuit of a normal life, he's actually nothing, which leads him to destructively sever himself from anything to which he has been close. Mann, like Aronofsky, shows how the economic systems in which these characters are trapped disallow them from realizing an idyllic dream existence or any moment of peace. They aren’t even allow them self-respect. This idea of exploitation is felt in Randy's relationship to his greasy boss (who watches porn in his office, continuing this motif of a civilization drenched in the simulated experience of closeness), much like Dennis Haysbert's relationship to his boss (Bud Cort) in Mann's Heat (1995), which was also about social structures that don't allow individuals to move forward.

Randy, the sacrificial Ram, enters the ring with The Ayatollah. At this moment, Pam realizes that she and Randy are the same. She begs him not to go in the ring. "I'm here," she pleads. "I'm really here." But Randy realizes that the only place he really exists is in the ring. Randy has lost his illusions, far ahead of the nostalgic fans who adore him, or the script of American righteousness conquering Islamic hatred. He doesn't exist in the real world, and never has. He decays as a wasted body, and will expire in the midst of action. Suffering chest pains, he ascends the top rope and prepares to do his finishing move in the All-American ritual of victory over the Evil Terrorist. He glances longingly at a window, seeing a place to which his soul can fly and finally be free from the Body (Aronofsky incorporates a certain Gnosticism that ties The Wrestler to his earlier films, The Fountain and Pi). He jumps out of the frame and the film ends.

***
The characters of The Wrestler struggle to make ends meet, its working class empathy making it perfect for the Springsteen song playing during the credits. It is a flurry of lost souls trapped by circumstances and occupation, imprisoned by their bodies in the Land of the Free, where the Body is negligible as health care is too expensive. These characters are far removed from technological means enabling success (I wonder if this will be one of the last contemporary films to feature a payphone; Kelly Reichardt's Wendy and Lucy, which The Wrestler closely resembles, may be the other). The American parable is re-enacted, though it's a sham (The Ayatollah isn't even Iranian; he's a light-skinned African American used car salesman). For many, Gus Van Sant's Milk is a timely motion picture that captures our need for hope and change in the coming age of Obama. But for me, as a liberal, The Wrestler is a much better showcase that perfectly captures the spirit of the present. It is a world where the middle class is evaporating, and people live paycheck to paycheck. The Body is at odds with Time.

The 1990s killed our sense of Time with the new forms of Information technology, while simultaneously they questioned the moral simplicity of the previous decade (like Kurt Cobain). The simpler era’s ideology has consequently crept back in the last eight years, being unveiled as something cancerous, in regards to our international and economic policies. The Wrestler communicates this sense in a raw fashion, calling its own realism to attention while also acknowledging its artifice and the artifice we construct in our rituals for entertainment and coherence. As the baby-boom generation ages, and healthcare only becomes more restrictive and expensive, the suffering lemmings fall over the cliff into a puddle of wasted flesh that is harder to turn away from, though difficult for us to stomach. For me, few motion pictures have been so timely in telling us where we are at.